Overconfidence in personnel selection: When and why unstructured interview information can hurt hiring decisions

ISI: Overconfidence in personnel selection: When and why unstructured interview information can hurt hiring decisions


2016 - Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes - Vol. 137, Noviembre, Pp 27-44


Overconfidence is an important bias related to the ability to recognize the limits of one’s knowledge. The present study examines overconfidence in predictions of job performance for participants presented with information about candidates based solely on standardized tests versus those who also were presented with unstructured interview information. We conducted two studies with individuals responsible for hiring decisions. Results showed that individuals presented with interview information exhibited more overconfidence than individuals presented with test scores only. In a third study, consisting of a betting competition for undergraduate students, larger overconfidence was related to fewer payoffs. These combined results emphasize the importance of studying confidence and decision-related variables in selection decisions. Furthermore, while previous research has shown that the predictive validity of unstructured interviews is low, this study provides compelling evidence that they not only fail to help personnel selection decisions, but can actually hurt them.


Judgment and decision making; Behavioral decision theory; Overconfidence; Hiring decisions; Personnel selection; Human resource management; Conscientiousness; General mental ability; Unstructured interviews; Evidence-based management.

¿Quieres seguir leyendo? [Accede a la publicación completa]

Investigación del Profesor Lyonel Lauilie es premiada como uno de los mejores papers de la Conferencia Academy of Managament 2018

El paper de denominado “He end is just the beginning: Turnover events and their impact across space and time” escrito por el Profesor Lyonel Laulie del área de Gestión de ...

Encuentro de Escucha de Voces Ciudadanas; Chile en el Amanecer del 2018

(Actividad que se realiza en coordinación con OPUS, Londres y con otros países del mundo)   Durante el mes de enero del presente año se realizó el Encuentro...

Todos los Derechos © 2014 | Departamento de Administración - Facultad de Economía y Negocios - Universidad de Chile - Diagonal Paraguay 257, torre 26, oficina 1101, piso 11, Santiago, Chile.